BIG CARTEL ALTERNATIVE

Everything Big Cartel does and the business it never grows into

Big Cartel is a lovely little shop for an artist selling a handful of things. It is cheap, it is simple, it takes no cut of your sales, and you can be selling by the afternoon. Most people who go looking for a Big Cartel alternative are not knocking it. They just outgrew it, and the product caps and bare-bones store started to bite.
Instinctor is what you move to when the side project becomes the business. It is one platform that is a real premium website, a real store with no product caps, bookings, smart chat and SEO, all at one flat price, and you own every bit of it. A store you grow into, not one you outgrow.

What Big Cartel gets right

It is worth being fair, because for what it is, Big Cartel is genuinely good. It is dead simple, it is cheap, there is a free tier, and it takes no transaction fees on your sales. For an artist, a maker or a small creative shop selling a few pieces, you can set it up in an afternoon and start selling without a manual.
So if you are selling a handful of products, you want the simplest possible shop, and you never plan to grow it into a bigger business, Big Cartel is a perfectly good home and this page is not for you. Where it starts to hurt is the day the shop turns out to be a real business.
The friction shows up the moment you want to grow. A handful of Big Cartel limits turn into real walls:

Where Big Cartel holds you back

  • You hit the product ceiling fast. Big Cartel caps how many products you can list, and the free tier is tiny. The moment your catalogue grows, you are shopping for a plan or shopping for a new platform.
  • It is a shop, not a website. Big Cartel gives you a storefront and little else. Real pages, a proper blog, a booking flow, an actual business around the products: none of that is really the point here.
  • The design controls are thin. A handful of simple themes and light tweaks. It looks clean, but it looks basic, and it looks like a Big Cartel shop.
  • SEO is barely there. A few fields and not much more. If you want to show up in Google and grow traffic over time, you are on your own.
  • You rent it, and you outgrow it. It is a lovely first step, but it is a first step. When the business gets serious, Big Cartel does not grow with you, so you end up rebuilding somewhere else anyway.

What Big Cartel will never do

A real store with no caps, and a real site around it. Big Cartel limits your products and stops at the shop. Instinctor gives you an unlimited catalogue, a checkout that is yours, and a full website wrapped around it: pages, blog, the works. One system, not a storefront with nothing behind it.
A site they remember, not a basic shop. A Big Cartel page looks clean and completely familiar. Instinctor was built by cinematographers, so every block lands looking expensive and your content moves through real 3D space. People stop, they remember, and they buy from the one that felt like more than a template.
An SEO engine, not a couple of fields. Big Cartel gives you the basics and wishes you luck. Instinctor gives every page a live 0 to 100 score and takes it to 100 in a few clicks, so you climb in Google from the day you launch instead of hoping someone finds the shop.
The whole business, not just a cart. Bookings with deposits, a store-aware smart chat, content and a real site in one place, instead of a shop that only sells and nothing else. One login, one flat price, and a platform that grows with you instead of capping you out.

Instinctor vs Big Cartel feature by feature

FeatureInstinctorBig Cartel
  • Unlimited productsYesLow caps
  • A real full websiteYesJust a shop
  • Visual drag-and-drop builderYesBasic themes
  • Template-free design, no two sites alikeYesTheme-based
  • Cinematic 3D scrollYesNo
  • Real store, Stripe checkoutYesBasic store
  • No cut taken on your salesYesYes
  • Bookings and deposits built inYesNo
  • Smart chat that knows your storeYesNo
  • Content, blog and real pagesYesNo
  • SEO score to 100, built inYesBasic
  • You own your siteYesYou rent it
  • We design and build it for youYesNo
Big Cartel pricing is refreshingly simple: a free tier for a couple of products, then a small monthly fee as you list more, with no cut on your sales. The catch is not the price, it is the ceiling. You are paying for a shop, and only a shop, so the day you need a real site, bookings or SEO, Big Cartel simply does not sell it at any price.
Instinctor is one flat price with everything included. The store with no product caps, the bookings, the smart chat, the content and the SEO are all in the box, there are no add-ons to stack, and we never take a percentage of a sale. You own the site outright and can cancel any time.

Moving your shop off Big Cartel

Big Cartel lets you export your product list, which is the easy part, but there is not much else to bring: the shop is the whole thing. Moving off it is less a migration and more an upgrade, because you are not leaving much behind, and you land on a faster, better-looking site that is a real business, not just a storefront.
We import your products, build the store and the full site around them, and set up redirects from your old Big Cartel URLs so anything you already rank for keeps its rankings through the move. Choose Managed and we do the entire rebuild for you, design and all.

Which one is right for you?

Choose Big Cartel if you are an artist or maker selling a handful of products, you want the simplest, cheapest shop you can stand up in an afternoon, and you are honestly not trying to build it into anything bigger. For that, it is a great little tool.
Choose Instinctor if the shop is becoming a real business: you want unlimited products, a premium website, bookings, smart chat and SEO in one place at one flat price, a design that is unmistakably yours, and a platform you own and never outgrow.

Simple pricing

Own your site. Cancel anytime. No transaction fees, ever.
Free
On WordPress.org
$0/mo
Visual builder, every block
Online store + Stripe checkout
Lead forms and smart chat, 30 replies/mo
Reviews, blog, galleries
SEO essentials
Perfect on every device
Most popular
Pro
You build it
$29.90/mo
Everything in Free
Real 3D depth and cinematic scroll
Unlimited smart chat, SMS and WhatsApp
Online bookings with deposits
Subscriptions, bundles, custom checkout
Advanced SEO with a 0-100 score
Instagent: whole sections from a brief
Pro Studio
Five sites, one plan
$79/mo
Everything in Pro
Up to 5 sites on one plan
One dashboard for every site
Built for studios and agencies

Common questions

No. Instinctor gives you an unlimited catalogue on one flat price. Big Cartel caps your products by plan and keeps the free tier tiny, which is the wall most people hit.
No, and neither does Big Cartel, which is one of the things it gets right. Checkout runs on your own Stripe account and Instinctor never takes a percentage of a sale.
Yes. We import your product list and build the store and full site around it. There is not much else to migrate off Big Cartel, so it is really an upgrade, and we can do the whole move for you.
Per month, Big Cartel can be cheaper, because it is only a shop. Instinctor is one flat price for a real store with no caps plus a full website, bookings, chat and SEO, so you are paying for a whole business instead of a storefront.
Yes. That is the whole point. You get a premium site with real pages, a blog and content around the store, not a storefront with nothing behind it the way Big Cartel works.
Yes. Bookings with real-time slots and deposits are built in and included. Big Cartel does not do bookings at all, so this is a common reason to move.
Instinctor gives every page a live 0 to 100 SEO score and takes it to 100 in a few clicks, so you climb from launch. Big Cartel SEO is barely there, which is why so many shops stay invisible.
Yes. Choose Managed and we design, build and migrate the entire site and store for you, then keep it running while you run the business.

Ready to outgrow Big Cartel?

Move up to a real store and a real website, keep your rankings, and stop bumping into caps. Start free on WordPress.org, or have us move you off Big Cartel and build the whole site for you.

Still weighing up the best Big Cartel alternative? Instinctor is the Big Cartel alternative built to sell: a premium website, a real store, bookings, smart chat and an SEO engine, all in one and all yours. Unlike the usual Big Cartel alternative, you own everything and pay one flat price. See why it is the Big Cartel alternative to beat in the full features and pricing, or compare the Wix alternative and Shopify alternative.

Explore more: Compare Instinctor · How-to guides · Business directory · All alternatives · BigCommerce alternative · Ecwid alternative · Foxy alternative · Gumroad alternative · Features and pricing

Instinctor
Built with Instinctor